Sep 09 2016

Future power: Challenges to integrating renewables

In late August 2016 AEMO released its report into the challenges and some solutions to maintaining power system security[i], or keeping the power flowing around Australia. The report Future Power System Security Program update outlines the challenges the National Electricity Market grid faces as we transition to high shares of renewable and distributed energy.

There is over 4 gigawatts (GW) of rooftop PV installed across the NEM - as a point of reference, the largest single power station in Australia, Eraring Power Station, has a capacity of 2.9 GW[ii]. Queensland currently has over 1.5 GW of rooftop PV installed, which is already comparable to the installed capacity of that state’s Gladstone Power Station (1.68 GW).

The challenges to maintaining power system security have come about because of the changing mix of generation, driven by policy. AEMO has identified the challenges as:

 

All of these changes are a result of the transition toward a decarbonised economy and the requirement to meet the 2030 emissions reductions target (to reduce emissions by 26-28 per cent from 2005 levels). As the cost of new technology falls and the Renewable Energy Target and jurisdictional policies increase renewable energy generation, meeting the power system challenges will become increasingly urgent. What this means is ensuring security of electricity supply, while also lowering emissions and decarbonising the economy in a cost-effective way.

Identified high priorities

Four key areas for further research into solutions were identified and immediately progressed by AEMO:

  1. Frequency control.
  2. Management of extreme power system conditions.
  3. Visibility of the power system (information, data, and models).
  4. System strength.

Frequency control involves keeping the network within a safe band of variation to maintain power supply and prevent damage to infrastructure. Traditional forms of frequency control involve governors, which were attached to power stations and automatically moderate and respond to frequency change, smoothing out deviations. Additionally, with high levels of inertia the rate of change of frequency was not as fast as it will be in the future, with lower levels of inertia. Non-synchronous generators, such as wind and solar, do not have this technology and do not currently supply frequency control services. Location, inverters and communication response time are the biggest limitations to new technologies such as batteries and wind providing frequency control services. Fast acting frequency response can be helpful to manage interconnector flows, however it needs to be located close to the interconnector to be effective. Fast frequency response alone (also called synthetic inertia) is not sufficient because it will always encounter a delay for detection and response[iii]. But fast frequency response can reduce the amount of synchronous inertia required to maintain power in large grids. In other words, fast frequency response is complementary to synchronous inertia, the two are only partial substitutes.

Managing extreme conditions on the grid is important to maintain power during heat waves, bush fires or other unplanned events that bring down infrastructure, such as an interconnector. Climate change and rising temperatures add to the risk to electricity infrastructure. These events can be thought of as risks to an amount of electricity supply during a year. The longer it takes to bring back supply, or the greater number of times a blackout occurs in a year, the greater the risk and cost to people and businesses. The chance of extreme conditions occurring is relatively small through the year, however the cost of them occurring is high and very disruptive, so it is important to mitigate the risk.

AEMO’s latest Electricity Statement of Opportunities report forecasts and outlines the risks of losing power in unplanned events and the resources available to mitigate these situations. The 2016 report results show that under a neutral economic and consumer outlook – and in the absence of new generation, network or non-network development – coal-fired generation withdrawals at the levels assumed[iv] may lead to breaches of the reliability standard[v]. The reliability of the power system is measured in the share of energy demand that is at risk in an adverse event (called unserved energy). Figure 1 shows that under assumptions of neutral economic growth and the withdrawal of 800MW of coal-fired generation in Victoria, in 2019-20 South Australia may see breaches of the reliability standard. Given the announced Victorian Renewable Energy Target which will increase non-synchronous generation in Victoria by around 5,000 MW by 2025[vi], it seems likely that AEMO’s forecasts will require measures to address the challenges in South Australia.

Figure 1: Forecast unserved energy and maximum demand, South Australia

Source: AEMO, 2016, Electricity Statement of Opportunities

System strength is a term AEMO uses to describe a power network that is robust to deviations, such as faults, and recovers quickly when an issue occurs in the system. Power systems with a high quantity of synchronous generation provide larger fault current and are categorised as strong systems. Fault levels vary throughout a network and are high in areas close to synchronous generation, and low in areas far from synchronous generation. In the NEM, the North West of Victoria is classed as having a weak system. Wind and solar generators that are non-synchronous use converters to match their output to the frequency of the system while maintaining voltage levels and power flows. In a weak system, these can fail through even minor disturbances.

As power generation becomes more distributed, with small scale solar and battery systems making up a larger share of total generation, the network operator will lose visibility of the state of the system and some of the tools to keep power flowing. To maintain power system security, a market operator needs accurate and up to date information on outputs from generation, power flows on transmission elements, and voltages across the grid. A market operator also needs good data on which to base forecasts, so it can plan ahead for outages or seasonal variations in wind and solar generation. In 2015, Europe’s transmission operators successfully mitigated the risk of lost solar generation due to a solar eclipse. The power system needed to continue to provide power through the forecast decrease in solar PV output of 20 GW at the start of the eclipse, and then a sudden power increase of 40 GW at the end[vii] (Figure 2). The planning and forecasts worked well due to the availability of good data on solar PV generation. This in turn was in part due to the higher proportion of utility-scale solar PV than is the case in Australia.

Figure 2: Power generation by country on the day of the solar eclipse in 2015

Source: European network of transmission system operators for electricity, 2016.

The challenges that AEMO has highlighted in integrating renewables are important, in order to transition Australia toward lower emissions while also maintaining secure electricity supply. Disruptions to supply of electricity, whether at the local or network-wide level are costly for households and businesses. Government policy has driven the pace and scale of change in the transition of the power system, and it is time that policy took a holistic, strategic look at solutions based on good data.

 


[i] AEMO, 2016, https://www.aemo.com.au/Electricity/National-Electricity-Market-NEM/Security-and-reliability/FPSSP-Reports-and-Analysis

[ii] AEMO, 2016, Submission to Queensland Renewable Energy Expert Panel – Issues Paper, https://www.aemo.com.au/Electricity/National-Electricity-Market-NEM/Security-and-reliability/-/media/595BFA726FE2419AAB1D07C5F018AC12.ashx

[iii] AEMO, 2016, https://www.aemo.com.au/Electricity/National-Electricity-Market-NEM/Security-and-reliability/-/media/91648DA6F36548E689F6A2D9075E121B.ashx

[iv] The level of coal-fired generation withdrawal assumed by AEMO is, NSW Liddell Power Station in 2022 and 800MW of power in Victoria by 2025-26 in response to COP21 Emissions reduction targets.

[v] AEMO, 2016, https://www.aemo.com.au/Electricity/National-Electricity-Market-NEM/Planning-and-forecasting/NEM-Electricity-Statement-of-Opportunities; AEMC, 2012, http://www.aemc.gov.au/getattachment/f93100d9-72d2-46fb-9c25-ac274a04ae58/Reliability-Standards-(to-apply-from-1-July-2012).aspx

[vi] Victorian Department of Economic Development, Jobs, Transport and Resources, 2016, http://www.energyandresources.vic.gov.au/energy/sustainable-energy/victorias-renewable-energy-targets

[vii] European network of transmission system operators for electricity, 2016, https://www.entsoe.eu/publications/position-papers/position-papers-archive/Pages/Position%20Papers/solar-eclipse-joint-report.aspx

Related Analysis

Analysis

Queensland’s pumped hydro plans

In September 2022, then Queensland Premier Annastacia Palaszczuk announced plans to construct two new pumped hydro projects: Borumba Dam – a 2GW facility located in Imbil, 50km west of Noosa, and the Pioneer/Burdekin facility which plans to offer 5GW of storage, located 75km west of McKay. We take a look at pumped hydro and how it can support the energy transition.

Apr 11 2024
Analysis

Gas outlook highlights peaking plant role in transition

Apart from raising some alarm bells over future potential gas shortfalls, the release of the Australian Energy Market Operator’s assessment of gas needs again highlighted the important role gas generation will play in the energy transition.  Gas generation is seen increasingly as a “strategic reserve for power system reliability and security” and “will be critical when it runs”. We take a look. 

Apr 04 2024
Analysis

Reviewing the Reviews, Part II

The first meeting of the Energy and Climate Change Ministerial Council (ECMC) for 2024 brought to the fore the extent of change underway in the energy sector. The ECMC’s communique hints at the breadth of reviews and assessments into the energy sector and operations of the National Electricity Market (NEM). It's part of a now long-established pattern. For well over a decade, energy has been at the forefront of policy developments, largely because of the significant changes to our grid. Along with those changes has come a heightened political involvement. With political interest has come a myriad of reviews, assessments and interventions to make the NEM “fit for purpose”. We take a look at the latest ECMC work and the extent of reviews underway.

Mar 07 2024
GET IN TOUCH
Do you have a question or comment for AEC?

Send an email with your question or comment, and include your name and a short message and we'll get back to you shortly.

Call Us
+61 (3) 9205 3100