A new report by EnergyQuest warns that LNG import projects are “urgently needed” in Melbourne and Sydney before 2026, to counter the risks of a growing shortage of gas in the southern states. This in turn may impact the contribution of gas-fired generation in our energy mix at a time when we anticipate more gas generation being needed to assist the transition to a lower emissions grid.
EnergyQuest’s East Coast Gas Outlook to 2036 report shows that gas production in NSW, Victoria, South Australia and Tasmania will be less than demand by 2022. By 2025, the annual gas production from offshore Victoria will more than halve, dropping to 146 petajoules (PJ) from 336 PJ in 2018.
Supply from Queensland would need to increase to almost one third of southern supply to fill this difference; however, EnergyQuest warns that more Queensland gas would only provide temporary relief.
“We also expect Queensland gas production to start declining from 2025, due to a shortage of quality gas resources,” EnergyQuest Chief Executive, Dr Graeme Bethune, said. “The east coast faces a double whammy of insufficient gas in both the north and south.”
According to the report, more reliance on Queensland gas will push up the wholesale price of gas delivered to Sydney and Melbourne to at least $10-13 per gigajoule (GJ) and for longer.
This obviously will have implications for the share of gas power generation (GPG) in the National Electricity Market (NEM), which has already been progressively declining since 2018, according to the Australian Energy Market Operator (AEMO)[i].
Figure 1 shows that electricity supplied by GPG reached its lowest quarterly average on record for the current GPG fleet (an average output of 3,184GWh, which is the lowest level since 2006).
Figure 1: Quarterly gas-powered generation
Source: AEMO Quarterly Energy Dynamics Report
AEMO’s Quarterly Energy Dynamics Report states that this is due to increased penetration of variable renewable energy (over 3GW of large-scale VRE commenced generation in the NEM during 2018), relatively high hydro output in 2018, and rising domestic and international gas prices in 2018.
EnergyQuest in its EnergyQuarterly December 2018 showed that gas use for NEM power was down 11.4 PJ in the third quarter of 2018 compared to the corresponding period 12 months earlier. Overall, this equated to a 25 per cent decrease in gas use for power generation with falls in all states. Like AEMO it points to key drivers being, increased wind and solar and hydro as higher wholesale gas prices. The drop in the third quarter of last year meant GPG’s share in the NEM fell from 9.5 per cent to 7 per cent.
In its latest assessment released this week, EnergyQuest found that the southern states’ need for a new permanent source of gas supply can only be met by proposed LNG import projects, which provide long-term supply confidence and transparent pricing. EnergyQuest says that blocking LNG import projects will increase prices, and instead they could provide increased competition in the east coast gas market. In addition to imports, the development of domestic projects is also critical, according to the report, which it states are slowed by political uncertainty and lengthy regulatory processes.
“LNG importing is not necessarily forever. Both Argentina and Egypt went from exporting LNG to importing and are now back into exporting following substantial gas discoveries,” Dr Bethune said.
During 2018 both domestic and international gas prices have been elevated. AEMO’s Quarterly Energy Dynamics Report shows that there were record wholesale gas prices despite low demand during Q4 of 2018.
During the quarter, Victoria’s Declared Wholesale Gas Market (DWGM) and the Short Term Trading Market (STTM) in Adelaide reached the highest average spot gas prices on record. The second highest on record was in the Brisbane and Sydney STTMs, and the Gas Supply Hub (GSH) (Figure 1). There was a 2-5 per cent increase in the price of trades over the quarter, with prices closing between $10.45-$10.95/GJ across the various 2019 products.
Figure 2: GSH. DWGM and STTM average quarterly prices
Source: AEMO Quarterly Energy Dynamics Report
AEMO states the increase was influenced by:
“Record high daily pipeline deliveries to Curtis Island for LNG export (3,583 TJ/day); comparatively high NEM electricity prices; and reduced supply from Longford compared to Q4 2017 (-29 per cent),which was offset by lower gas-powered generation (GPG) demand. These domestic gas price results occurred despite a 33 per cent drop in international Brent prices (oil) and a related fall in LNG netback pricing.”
Looking to the US
The price of gas is also a key factor in the share of gas in the US generation mix. Natural gas makes up a larger proportion of the US generation mix (34 per cent), compared to Australia (11.8 per cent) for 2018. Recently the US Energy Information Administration (EIA) noted the mix of fuels used to generate electricity in the US has changed in response to differences in the relative costs of electricity-generating technologies and their fuels.
The EIA report provides modelled projections of domestic energy markets from today through to 2050. The agency uses the National Energy Modelling System, which looks at interactions of economic changes and energy supply, demand and prices, and includes side cases that represent different assumptions to reflect possible future events in the US energy markets.
As shown in figure 2 below, in the High Oil and Gas Resource and Technology scenario – which includes low natural gas prices - natural gas provides 54 per cent of all US electricity generation by 2050, while the natural gas generation share drops to around 21 per cent in the Low Oil and Gas Resource and Technology scenario, which assumes high natural gas prices.
The report’s baseline - or Reference Case - assumes trend improvements in known technologies and acts on the assumption of current laws and regulation. In 2018, natural gas accounted for 34 per cent of total electricity generation, and it is expected that this share will grow to 40 per cent by 2032 and then remain at around 40 per cent throughout 2050. Relatively low natural gas prices are expected to lead to more use of existing plants as well as increased natural gas power plant construction.
Figure 3: National gas fuel price to electric generators and share of generation (2000-2050)
Natural gas exceeded coal in 2016 as the fuel most used to generate electricity in the US, and in the EIA’s Reference Case, it continues to lead US electricity generation throughout the projection period (Figure 4). It is expected that the rise in natural gas will support increasing consumption in the electric and industrial power sectors as well as higher levels of exports. Natural gas prices also remain relatively low and steady during the period (when compared with historical prices) leading to its increased use, and as such, electricity generation shares from coal and nuclear gradually decline as they become less cost competitive compared with natural gas and renewables.
Figure 4: Electricity generation from selected fuels (1990-2050)
In the High Oil and Gas Resource and Technology case, the share of natural gas-fired generation is significantly higher (when compared to the Reference Case) with natural gas-fired plants additionally surpassing renewables as the leading source of new capacity additions.
While the Low Oil and Gas Resource and Technology case shows natural gas-fired generation becoming less competitive, increased additions of solar photovoltaic and wind capacity make renewables the main source of electricity generation in this case, first surpassing coal-fired plants as the primary source of generation by the mid-2020s and then exceeding natural gas-fired generation before 2030.
[i] AEMO Quarterly Energy Dynamics Report
North Queensland attracts its fair share of debate around electricity. Since around 2009 there has been a push to develop a major transmission line – now CopperString 2.0 (CopperString) – to connect Mt Isa to the National Electricity Market. Discussion around the CopperString proposal has come back into focus recently with submissions to the Queensland Government on electricity supply options for the North-West Minerals Province. Here we take a closer look at the CopperString proposal, the project’s background, options moving forward and the costs and benefits.
The transition of the energy grid continues apace and its impacts on how the system operates continue to evolve. The latest GenInsights21 report provides valuable insights into some of the key trends that are emerging, this is based on analysis of extensive generation data. We take a look at its assessment of the expansion of rooftop solar and the implications for the grid.
The latest discussion paper in the Australian Energy Council’s series on Australia’s Energy Future focuses on the need for zero emissions dispatchable plant to complement the growth of renewable energy and the retirement of existing coal and gas generation. It also considers the types of zero emissions dispatchable power currently available.
Send an email with your question or comment, and include your name and a short message and we'll get back to you shortly.